False Data?? I think so… -Brenda H

After reading the last chapter of Rigor Mortis, “Inventing a Discipline”, I learned about a new type of research. Meta-Research. Now, Meta-Research isn’t the study of Metahumans like on The Flash… The scientists who do Meta-Research basically do research on research. They try to find different ways to make research better which is something I’d say we definitely need now looking back at the chapters I’ve previously read. As Goodman stated; “Most of the time what we find out was that the data were horrible,” (Pg 218) He also stated that most of the time they would honestly conclude that despite all the data, they didn’t know what was going on. This conclusion to me was definitely a shocking surprise, I would always come to think that scientists would come to a certain conclusion using their correct data. I didn’t realize there was even research on research but this is obviously an important study someone out there should do.

Fake Facts??
Jumping to Conclusions…

 I also came to learn that scientists were still citing their original disapproved study, as Goodman said “This is one major reason why having lots of false results circulating in the literature is not a good idea. These results get entrenched. You cannot get rid of them,” (Pg 220) This is, in fact, true because there are some people that don’t even know what they are dealing AKA disapproved data!! But end up using it anyway. We should have some sort of online fact checker to make sure the data is correct or to tell you whether it was done today or is centuries old. I myself did some outside research to look for any situations like this and found a forensic drug case. 34,000 criminal cases were questioned, Scientist Annie Dookhan was found to have falsified records on the case. She forged signatures and did not perform the research. She pretended to be her patients and made up her own data. This ended up getting people wrongly imprisoned as well as the people who were rightly accused to be freed. I personally think that this situation is awful! Imagine being imprisoned for something you didn’t do but “Facts” say you are guilty? All because a scientist falsified records on your case. I always thought scientists were super smart and always knew what they were doing, but thankfully people like us started to question scientists and they are hopefully getting better with their research. If scientists don’t keep up with their research imagine how much money is going towards their false research and work? I found the following;  Data from ongoing surveys by the National Science Foundation (NSF) show that federal agencies provided only 44% of the $86 billion spent on basic research in 2015. They still used “Only” as if it were too little for the type of research they are doing. Incredible.


-Brenda H

2 thoughts on “False Data?? I think so… -Brenda H

Add yours

  1. Lily D.

    Wow. I also didn’t know that people did research on research, but i’m happy that they do. Through learning more about medical research it is very concerning that you aren’t actually getting truthful and reliable information. I want to know more about what type of qualifications you need or how you even get into becoming a Meta-Reasercher. I think that you did a very good job at writing about the highlights of the chapter, providing external information, and clearly stating your thoughts about this last chapter. God job!

  2. I really liked how the author added outside information, her opinion and ways she thinks we can fix the problem. I certainly agree with her idea on how there should be a system were scientists data is checked. As medicine updates over time and improves, scientist ability to do research correctly and property should continue to thrive overtime, and certainly that is something we need to work on and improve. Nicely done!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

A WordPress.com Website.

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: