“Women deserved pain”, Oh My! -Truc L.

“Women deserved pain” (1).

My lower jaw drops reading this sentence. The book starts with Eve the first pregnant woman; she was cursed by God for eating forbidden after. God told her,

“I greatly multiply your pain childbearing; in pain, you shall bring forth children” (1).

This idea sets a mindset for women giving birth from Antiquity through the Middle Ages. Birthing was considered spiritually not medically. I was baffled by some of the beliefs of pregnancy and remedies. The misconceptions cannot be helped in the earlier time. The people didn’t have tools to explore the subject. Many were afraid of the idea
and didn’t bother to bring it up. At that time, birth was another mystery of the human life cycle.

L0041837 Child in womb
Sixteenth– century illustration of fetuses in the womb. Eucharis Rösslin.

Even if there were many debates between midwives and doctors to which is better, the woman and child were ever truly “safe” in any of those agents. It wasn’t until the 1600s when we first see a medical tool that was used during childbirth. Before mostly midwives handle child birthing, men were not allowed to enter the birthing room. The Chamberlen family designed obstetric forceps and medical men were introduced. The forceps helped the process of difficult birthing a little easier and safer.

“These men had the highest success rates for getting the baby out safely and keeping the new mother alive, thanks to their secret tool” (17).

The Obstetric Forceps

After looking at some pictures of how a forceps are used, I wonder if you could hurt the baby while pulling the head out like that.


Using Forceps


With curiosity I asked my dad [he was a nurse in Viet Nam and assisted childbirth] if he used the forceps during delivery, he said no. He told me that mostly use hands, and if the baby is stuck then they would use the vacuum extractor to pull the baby out.


Vacuum extractor



Forceps vs Vacuum extraction


But even then there still risks for injuring the baby.
As I continue reading, I learned about vesicovaginal fistulas and rectovaginal fistulas and how Dr. J Marion Sims found a way to repair the tears. I thought of him as a hero as first, but as I get further into the chapter, I changed my mind. Using slave as test subjects is evil. What disturbs me the most is not using anesthesia.

“African-Americans had a higher threshold for pain compared with civilized Caucasians” (44).


This statement made me cringed. But even so with Dr. Sims inhumane experiments, I’m still thankful for his discovery.

J. Marion Sims with Anarcha, Betsey, and Lucy and two physician partners


Furthermore, into the book, I learn about the danger of Childbed Fever and its causes. Childbed fever is caused by Streptococcus pyogenes. I right away remember what I learned in Biomed, about bacteria. They are deadly, but staying sanitary can prevent infections.

“They only way a woman got childbed fever was by having a contaminated hand or instrument inserted during delivery” (61).

I also read about Lying In and Maternity Wards, and I prefer giving birth at an official place than my house. Back then it didn’t seem like it was a good idea, but now after seeing how some of the places looks like, I think a place like this is more hygienic than my house.
Finally, after reading about painless childbirth, I took interest and search up Twilight Sleep. I was looking for more information but couldn’t find much. I realized it was dangerous and they didn’t use it anymore. I was really excited that painless childbirth was birth was possible, but I guess we are not there yet. The closest to painless childbirth is getting a C-section when you under heavy anesthetic, but even then you still feel pain afterward. The maternal mortality rates are still high, but I see progress.

I relatively enjoyed the book so far, there are some uncomfortable passages but overall it is good.

3 thoughts on ““Women deserved pain”, Oh My! -Truc L.

Add yours

  1. I think everything you said and all your reactions were true and fair. Women were meant to suffer because of how society viewed birth. “Women were meant to suffer” that’s how people thought, because giving birth was supposed to be something glorious, and enduring the pain of delivery meant strength and the ability to raise children, obviously this idea of birth is dated and most people in the world don’t believe in this. I think society doesn’t think like this anymore because of how medicine has progressed in such a short time. When you think about it, it has only been around 100 years that medicine has really become a big thing. I think society has influenced views on medicine, and medicine has influenced society. If you found someone eating a pizza off the street you think “Ew, gross” because medicine and research have proved that germs live in unsanitary things, this is an example of how medicine has influenced society. Hundreds of years ago doctors and medicine wasn’t progressing because it wasn’t held to a high standard (this is a way society influenced medicine). Great blog Truc! -Celeste O.

  2. Wow Truc, your post was the most eye catching post I saw, and I just had to reply. I agree that black slaves shouldn’t be treated as specimens and experimented on. You clearly went into depth with your research and curiosity. You also stated your quotes and images clearly with no confusion as to which these tools went to. My reaction was the same as yours, I was completely intrigued but was also uncomfortable with some sections of the book. You express a great knowledge and great learning ability. Great blog post overall! -Emma W.

  3. It seems we had very similar reactions when beginning this book! Like you, I can remember being completely unprepared for the topics covered in this book and for the way the author spoke about difficult topics plainly without softening or dancing around the truth. In your post I especially liked the way you talked about real experiences your family had, as well as your own opinions,

    -Kayla Z.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

A WordPress.com Website.

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: